This isn’t hypothetical. I’ve kept my ponies at multiple farms where they lived out 24/7 with no shelter—or with shelter most people would call “inadequate.” Maybe a dozen days a year the weather was rough enough that I put a blanket on and tossed extra hay to keep them comfortable. Those days were the exception. The other 350? They were happy. Grazing, running, interacting, living like horses.
I can’t emphasize enough how important turnout is for a horse’s mental and physical health. Yes, some horses like to duck inside during a cold rain or to escape bugs. But what about the rest of the time? What do people imagine their horse is doing in that stall?
Many horses spend 12, 18, even 24 hours a day inside. Let’s be generous and say a horse gets eight hours of turnout—which is more than many New England barns offer. That means 16 hours in a box just large enough to turn around. No entertainment, no movement, no social life. How would you handle that? When I see horses weaving, pinning their ears, lunging at passersby, chewing walls, or looking half-dead and shut down, I’m amazed we don’t recognize those behaviors for what they are: the same miserable coping mechanisms we see in zoo animals. I once knew a woman who electrified the inside of her horse’s stall to stop him from chewing the wood. The horse didn’t need electrified walls—he needed out.
And the physical consequences are real. Anyone who works a desk job knows how a sedentary life affects the body. Horses were built to move, not stand still on hard footing for hours. Lack of circulation, stiff joints, stress on tendons and hooves. These things are solved by movement. Turnout is the answer, not memory foam footing.
Turnout also matters for conditioning. I stopped working with a client years ago because her horses lived stalled unless the weather was perfect. “Turnout” meant stepping into a 14 x 14 outdoor box. She had actual paddocks, but I saw the horses out there maybe five times in eight months. Her horses weren’t overflowing with energy—they were gasping for air after two minutes of work. One gelding arrived looking strong and muscular; within five months, his back had dropped, his muscle tone evaporated, and he struggled to trot a few laps while carrying her. I finally couldn’t watch it anymore and stopped working for her.
So what is adequate turnout? A horse needs space to move at the walk, trot, and canter on its own. A bare minimum is about 80 ft x 80 ft, and bigger is always better. Varied terrain, grazing (when appropriate), and the presence of herd mates make an enormous difference.
Despite the overwhelming benefits, stalling is so normalized that it’s hard for people to question it. I often hear, “My horse loves to come in,” or “He waits at the gate.” What they’re not acknowledging is that they feed the horse immediately after bringing it in. Horses love food—not confinement.
Another common argument: “My horse could never adapt to living outside.” In my experience, the human has a much harder time adapting than the horse. Any anxiety people observe—pacing at the gate, for example—usually has more to do with strict feeding schedules than the turnout itself. Every horse who has come to me for training has lived outside, sometimes with minimal shelter, and I’ve never seen one genuinely struggle to adjust. They might be uncertain about a new environment, but within a day they’re grazing, napping, and clearly not longing for a stall.
People also worry their horse will injure itself if turned out in mud, or in a big paddock, or for too many hours. Yes—if a horse is confined most of the time, under-conditioned, and then suddenly released into a large space, it might explode with pent-up energy and slip. But those of us whose horses live outside can tell you: injuries are far less common. Conditioned horses navigate all kinds of footing—even ice—with balance and confidence. Honestly, lack of turnout is more likely to cause injury than turnout itself. And we rarely acknowledge the emotional cost we force the horse to pay in the name of “soundness.”
In short, it’s obvious how strongly I feel about this. I’ve seen horses who never go outside and horses who live on 20 acres. The difference in their mental state is staggering. I often tell owners with limited turnout that they might not even need a trainer if they simply improved their horse’s living situation. Caring for a horse’s emotional well-being comes first—and adequate turnout isn’t optional. It’s essential.
Videos of horse playing and making the most of adequate turnout with friends:
Leave a Reply